Isnt't 3 toomuch?
Usually two are enough, and the third one is added if any of the two previous ones raises some serious doubts.
I think 2 peer reviewers are enough but in some special cases third one might be added.
Senad
Two are enough. The Editor should also have a sound knowledge in the relevant field.
Three okay if the final decision based on two.
I think two not enough because some time they have different opinion .
Regards, Azzam
Two is enough if there comments are almost same.
Usually a manuscript is sent for two peer reviewers. But sometimes one of the reviewers give straightway rejection whereas another reviewer suggest minor/major corrections. In such a case, manuscript is evaluated by the third reviewer.
We have a manuscript accepted by a good journal. Our institute pays for only one article per researcher per year and they have already paid for one. I have also paid for 2 but now broke. Who else...
09 October 2018 4,940 0 View
We had an accepted manuscript and we are collaborating with one institution in South Africa. When the South African institution received the invoice for the manuscript, the pronounced that they...
07 August 2018 3,661 2 View
Are there any guidelines?
07 August 2018 4,846 4 View
I have often times got references from the reference section of an article that I read. I then search for these citations and go on to read them. My question is "Do I have an obligation to also...
05 June 2018 5,957 4 View
What does your official University/Institution policy say about this
03 April 2018 7,125 5 View
5, 10, 20 , 50 100. Distinguish between a teaching lecturer and a non teachingresearcher
03 April 2018 2,162 5 View
Some journals request you to nominate colleagues to review your manuscript. If you know that a colleague is reviewing your manuscript, should you avoid meeting him for fear of biasing his judgement
02 March 2018 6,132 3 View
Each and everyone of us has a different style of writing that captures his or her readers. Isn't the function of reviewers to check facts?
02 March 2018 7,970 3 View
We have peer evaluation but I think the system may be abused by colleagues also competing for promotion
02 March 2018 677 26 View
I am a reviewer for 4 journals and I continue to receive requests to review manuscripts for journals. Where should i draw the line? I have a full teaching load and I am also expected to perform...
02 March 2018 3,084 13 View
Hi there! I regularly receive suggestion about papers and authors that are totally out of my area. Does anybody know how I can fix this? Thank you!
01 March 2021 9,574 4 View
Could you please recommend some good journal that accept very long revie papers (approximately 6000+ words) in neurosurgery, cancer biology ?
01 March 2021 8,087 3 View
I have come up with a method and had written a paper on it. Paper got rejected by a journal stating that there is no theoretical novelty. I am kind of confused on why the novelty that I am able to...
28 February 2021 2,393 8 View
As a former management practitioner, I recall a generally accepted view that changing organisational culture is difficult, so you should only attempt it if the organisational change that you are...
27 February 2021 2,595 8 View
How much value does a review paper carry in a higher study aspirant student's profile which is presented in a Peer Reviewed Scopus Indexed conference?
27 February 2021 2,068 3 View
26 February 2021 7,279 2 View
How was your publication experience with BBRJ in terms of peer review and reviewer comments. Did you find it fair and transparent ?
23 February 2021 3,810 6 View
I am looking for a classification of the research methods included in literature review papers or Meta analysis ones .
22 February 2021 1,131 4 View
we are co-authors of several publications. But I am the only and single author of most of my publications which are based on my own research. How can I separate the profiles?
21 February 2021 4,582 3 View
Hello, I have read in a few publications that to extract total DNA from sputum samples, both bead beating and enzymes are used to disrupt the cells. Bead beating is supposed to be efficient in...
18 February 2021 3,360 2 View