Hello everyone
i hope to help, i was sent my article to a journal and I got some revision
one of the reviewer comments was :
((According to Table 1, the value of corrosion rate (icorr) corresponds to the change of two parameters: temperature and Ecor. Thus, corrosion at different temperatures occurs under conditions of different potentials. To exclude the influence of two factors simultaneously - temperature and potential - the determination of the corrosion rate at different temperatures should be carried out under conditions of maintaining a constant potential. Therefore, it is incorrect to use the Arrhenius equation and the transition state equation at a changing value of Ecor. But since the author did not maintain the value of Ecor constant with a change in temperature, the values of Ea, ΔH and ΔS given in the article are not true, but are apparent or effective. The author must indicate this in the article”.))
why not I can use Arrhenius eq.?
i attach the data
I hope to help me with how I can reply to the reviewer??
Sir, its very easy just find correlation equation between two variables, or three variables, you can do online with any mathematical tool, you can also find regression equations.. from this u can answer it, its easy..u try..if you cant do , i can assist you
I agree with Mr. Akula,s suggestion of trying to find the correlation between the two variables. Alternatively, I think the easy option would be to agree with reviewer's suggestion that the values you calculated are not true but effective in getting to the conclusion.
- Badges
- Science topic
- Similar topics
- Physical Sciences
- Materials Science
- Materials
- Inorganic Materials
- Ceramics
- Glass