Should I calculate total organic carbon from biochar through loss on ignition Methode?

Calculating total organic carbon (TOC) in biochar using the Loss on Ignition (LOI) method is a common approach, but it's important to understand both its strengths and limitations. Here is a detailed and comprehensive analysis:

Loss on Ignition (LOI) Method Overview

The LOI method involves heating the biochar sample to a high temperature to oxidize and volatilize organic carbon compounds. The weight loss observed during this process is attributed to the combustion of organic carbon.

Steps Involved in LOI Method

Sample Preparation:Dry the biochar sample to a constant weight at a lower temperature (usually around 105°C) to remove moisture. Weigh the dried sample accurately.

Ignition:Place the dried sample in a muffle furnace. Heat the sample to a specific temperature (commonly 550°C) for a predetermined period (typically 2-4 hours). This temperature is chosen because it is high enough to combust organic carbon but low enough to avoid significant loss of inorganic carbonates.

Post-Ignition:Cool the sample in a desiccator to prevent moisture absorption. Weigh the sample again.

Calculation:The difference in weight before and after ignition represents the loss of organic matter, which is assumed to be primarily organic carbon.

LOI (%)=(Initial weight−Final weight)/Initial weight×100

Advantages of LOI Method

Simplicity: The method is straightforward and does not require complex instrumentation.

Cost-Effective: Requires basic laboratory equipment like a muffle furnace and analytical balance.

Widely Used: Commonly accepted method for determining organic content in various materials, including soils and sediments.

Limitations of LOI Method

Specificity: LOI measures the total volatile content, which includes not only organic carbon but also water, volatile inorganics, and other combustible materials.

Accuracy: The method may overestimate TOC if the sample contains significant amounts of carbonates, which decompose at high temperatures.

Temperature Sensitivity: Accurate temperature control is critical. Too low a temperature may result in incomplete combustion of organic carbon, while too high a temperature may lead to decomposition of inorganic compounds.

Inconsistent Results: Different types of biochar with varying compositions might yield inconsistent results due to the presence of refractory organic compounds or varying ash content.

Alternative Methods

Given the limitations of LOI, alternative methods for determining TOC in biochar might be considered:

Elemental Analysis (CHN Analyzer): Direct measurement of carbon, hydrogen, and nitrogen content using combustion and detection techniques.

Thermogravimetric Analysis (TGA): Measures weight loss in a controlled atmosphere and provides detailed decomposition profiles.

Wet Chemical Methods: Use of chemical oxidation and titration to determine organic carbon content, though these methods can be more complex and labor-intensive.

Recommendations

Use LOI with Caution: If you choose the LOI method, be aware of its limitations and ensure proper sample preparation and temperature control.
Supplement with Other Methods: Consider confirming LOI results with more precise techniques like elemental analysis to improve accuracy.
Standardization: Follow standardized protocols, such as those provided by ASTM or ISO, to ensure consistency and reliability of results.

Conclusion

While the LOI method is a viable option for estimating TOC in biochar due to its simplicity and cost-effectiveness, its limitations necessitate careful consideration and possibly supplementary analysis. For accurate and reliable results, combining LOI with other methods or validating with more precise techniques is recommended.

Can we mark 'EFL Learners shifting from general digital to AI technologies' as technological transition?

How to generate a citation of my paper from ResearchGate?

Does Anyone have expertise in in vitro transcription and RNA pull down assay?

How to fix background error in rietveld refinement of one XRD peak using GSAS-II?

Why might the impedance values for DI water and 0.1X PBS buffer solution exhibit a decreasing and increasing trend, respectively over time (HP 4194A)?

How can I add own Henry coefficients in Aspen Plus?

Can usage of AI tools like chat GPT in research work is recommendable ?

Usage of internal standards in LC-MS/MS analysis?

ANY free software for reconstructing neurons in the microscopic image?

How effective is the Citi Bloc standard basket in enhancing the accuracy and comparability of international construction cost assessments?

• What the possible Persistent Organic Pollutants and Heavy metals present in fluorspar, sediments, and water bodies around its mining area?

What is the reason for current dropping in OER , LSV curve?

Adhesion strength of coating?

Basis set and input instruction to calculate HOMO and LUMO using Orca for Imidazolium based organic salts?

Do interactions between biosphere, carbon cycle, & water cycle impact global warming & interaction between atmosphere & hydrosphere?

Separation of organic acids-HPLC?

Who of all of you will help TPEOM to re-originate the Earths atmosphere to it original 5 atmospheric elements/gases?

How to convert g/kg Humic acid dose to kg/ha?

How can I separate graphene from amorphous carbon of similar particle sizes?

Question about combustion Kinetics ?