No longer available (why can't I delete my own question)?

Sita Drost First, let me reassure you that such discrepancies are not uncommon in scientific research, and they often lead to valuable insights.

Now, let's break it down in simple terms:

Direct Solution (Your Approach):You're using the piezoelectric equations directly, solving for the transducer's response. Your results for transmitted force (F0) seem fine, but when you calculate received voltage (V = I * ZE), you notice it's twice as high as your collaborator's.

Mason's Model (Your Collaborator's Approach):Your collaborator uses Mason's equivalent electrical circuit. They calculate transmitted force and then use the reciprocity theorem to determine received voltage.

Here's where the difference might be coming from:

It's possible that your direct solution is accounting for certain terms twice, leading to the factor of 2 difference. Double-check your equations and ensure that you're not inadvertently duplicating any terms during the calculation.
Additionally, Mason's model might have assumptions or simplifications that differ from your direct approach. These differences can affect the final results.
Collaborate closely with your experienced colleague and carefully compare the two methods step by step. Discuss the assumptions, boundary conditions, and any simplifications made in both approaches. This collaborative effort can help pinpoint the source of the discrepancy.

Remember, in scientific research, discrepancies often lead to new discoveries and a deeper understanding of the problem. Keep your discussions respectful and open, as this collaborative approach will likely lead to a solution.

#PiezoelectricEquations #MasonsModel #ResearchChallenges #ScientificCollaboration #ReciprocityTheorem #PiezoelectricResponse #ScientificDiscovery #ProblemSolving #ScientificCommunity #ResearchCollaboration #PhysicsResearch #AcademicJourney #ScientificInquiry #LearningFromExperts #UnderstandingComplexSystems

Qamar Ul Islam

Sita Drost , I appreciate your thorough approach. In science, the journey towards understanding is often as valuable as the destination. Since both methods theoretically align, and your detailed comparison hasn't resolved the discrepancy, consider these additional aspects:

Material Properties Variation: In piezoelectric systems, material properties can significantly impact results. Small variations in material constants used in the equations might lead to large differences in outcomes.

Measurement and Instrumentation Errors: Review the calibration and precision of instruments used in measuring force and voltage. Even subtle errors can skew results.

Environmental Factors: Temperature, humidity, or external vibrations might affect your experiments. Ensure environmental conditions are consistent and controlled.

Frequency Dependence: Piezoelectric response can be frequency-dependent. Check if both approaches account for this in the same manner.

Numerical Approximations: If you're using computational methods, differences in numerical approximations or algorithms could be a factor.

Human Factor: Revisit each step with a fresh perspective or involve a third party for an unbiased review. Sometimes, a new set of eyes can catch overlooked details.

Remember, resolving such complex discrepancies is a testament to the rigor and diligence required in scientific inquiry. Your persistence and collaboration are key in unraveling these mysteries. Keep questioning, exploring, and sharing – that's the essence of our scientific journey.

Is it possible that invitro inhibition of alpha glucosidase activity always show antidiabetic effect invivo?

What is an analytical expression for the ZZ graphene edge state?

How accurate is the shear modulus measured using PROCEQ DPC transducer of 40kHZ frequency on 100mm concrete cube specimen?

How do you improve retroviral expression from PG13 cells?

Do I need to transfect FuW-tetO-MCS and FUW-M2rtTA plasmids together in HEK293T or separately?

Best time-point to determine changes in mRNA via qPCR?

Is there any way to calibrate transducer without needle hydrophone?

How to convert mV output into MPa?

Modeling and Simulation of Radial Piezoelectric Transducer?

Transduction of mouse primary neurons with AAVs, protocol?

Hi can anyone recommend a synovial cell line?

Why does transduction MDA-MB and MV-3 with lentivirus and PEI not work?