I want to analyze inorganic ions in aerosol samples, where the sample size and concentrations both are very small. Please suggest any suitable method for ion analysis other than IC.
Dear Manish, I recommend you to read to my colleague Gustavo Delgado I give you the link http://www.lamjol.info/index.php/UNIVERSITAS the suggest use the Maple 13 programm.
Aerosol which is usually colloids of fine solid particles with the range of 0.001 to 100 microns in size. These are inorganic particles with very low concentration. In this regard not much work has been carried out. However the instrument like ICP-MS can be try which can analyse Ca and Mg of your concerned. For other ions and in this very very low concentration some method have to be evaluated. Which can determine the ions in part per trillion
I guess you want to analyze on metals in PM. Voltammetry might be a relatively cheap alternative for ion chromatography and surely compared to ICP-MS. This is the technique where Carlos Gonzalez is pointing to. See for performance characteristics in the air quality field for instance: http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1352231006003943, where voltammetry is compared with ICP-MS. For anions, there is hardly an alternative to ion chromatography, as far as I know.
If I understood well, what you want to determine is the concentration of elements such as sulfur or chlorine. A rather cheap alternative is x-ray fluorescence, which would not only give information on these lements, but also many others including metals. Of course, it is more difficult to obtain data about the chemical state of the elements, although it is possible using wavelength dispersive spectrometers. Another advantage of XRF is that it is not destructive, so you can further analyze your samples with other methods. However, it is necessary to deposit the samples onto special filters, such as teflon or polycarbonate. But this a fast, low-cost alternative.
I have to analyze inorganic ions like Sulphate, nitrates, chlorides, Bromides, ammonium, calcium and Magnesium in ionic forms. We have Ion chromatograph with us, but there is some problem in it which cannot be resolved now. so I am looking for some alternative options.
All parameters can be done together with the help of Ion Chromatograph. As far as the analysis of sulphates and nitrates from spectrophotometer is concerned, it is ok for higher concentrations i.e. ppm level, but in the atmospheric aerosols concentrations may be in ppb which is not possible to be analyzed with spectrophotometer. Second thing is that, sample size is very less in aerosol samples. spectrophotometer will not fulfill the purpose. Regarding Ca and Mg are concerned AAS gives total Ca and Mg. I am looking for Ca+2 and Mg+2.
Your question evokes old memories of methods almost forgotten (by me too), like nephelometry for sulfates and chlorides. If you cannot fix your IC, than this may be a valid alternative, It's anyway interesting to look into these old methods. See for instance this one; "THE CONCENTRATION OF CHLORIDE, SODIUM, POTASSIUM, CALCIUM, AND SULFATE IN RAIN WATER OVER THE UNITED STATES" link:
You mention that you need the concentration of the Ca and Mg ions, but for what reason and at what dilution of the sample? and at what pH? and should this be identical to the situation at which IC works?
Harry, in aerosol Ca and Mg are present usually in very low concentration. Perhaps in part per trillion. And pH is usually mildly acidic to neutral and it depend upon the sources of aerosol ,furthermore,this may not be identical to the satuation at which IC work.
"In both campaigns, calcium was found to be the predominant component of the coarse fraction while crust-related aluminosilicates and iron were the other major components"
Also Mg can be substantial, for instance in aerosol from fireworks.
I repeat my question (to Marish) 1. why he needs the conc of the ionic form and 2. whether this applies to their presence in the aerosol or in the analytic solution
I want to use the mass concentrations of these ions as input to receptor models for the source apportionment of aerosols and it applies to their presence in aerosols.also for better understanding of aerosols formation mechanism. Additionally Indian aerosols are mostly alkaline in nature.
In case Indian aerosol is alkaline I presume the calcium and magnesium are present as the carbonates. However these are not very soluble species so why are you then interested in the ionic species of these elements for source apportionment. In that case the source aerosol must be classified in the same way. So do you have the source profiles and are these assessed according to compounds?