Is it ethical for a reviewer to suggest rejecting a paper they evaluated with ChatGPT's assistance?

More Ahmed Tijani Salawudeen's questions See All

Is There Any Feasible Method To Test Fluorescent Compounds Other Than Fluorescence Spectrometers ??

Is There Any Feasible Method To Test The Efficiency Of Fluorescent Compounds Other Than UV Spectrometers ? Suggestions Would Be Appreciated !

02 March 2021 5,785 3 View

What is the characteristic length to determine the Reynolds number for the scattered turbulent fluid flow?

Dear all, I just saw this example in FB on the difference between laminar flow and turbulent flow. The flow from a pipe hits the sink and scattered. The flow from the pipe is characterized as...

02 March 2021 1,999 5 View

I am interested in medicinal chemistry field, which books are highly recommended to learn from?

I am at the beginner level in drug design and drug discovery, and I am interested to learn more about this field. Which books are highly recommended to start from and gives me all essential...

02 March 2021 8,437 2 View

Could you please recommend some good journal that accept very long revie papers (approximately 6000+ words) in neurosurgery, cancer biology ?

01 March 2021 8,087 3 View

Does anyone have kinetic and kinematic dataset for gait classification?

I want to differentiate between normal and abnormal movement. For this reason, I am looking forward to this type of dataset.

01 March 2021 9,485 1 View

How to assign different material properties to each element in Abaqus ?

Hello, I am writing a python script to generate my model and write the input file. The problem is I have 1000 elements in my mesh and I want to assign different material properties to each...

01 March 2021 9,511 3 View

How to choose ANN number of hidden layers and nodes?

Hello, Could you please share any interesting research explaining how to choose the number of hidden layers and nodes per layer in case of regression problems using ANN? Thank you, any help would...

01 March 2021 6,200 3 View

What is the best way to calculate the angles of twist for concrete columns subjected to torsional moment using finite element software?

In Finite element software like ANSYS , there is difficulty in obtaining direct results of twisting of concrete members because SOLID65 which is the unique element designed to represent concrete...

26 February 2021 3,806 2 View

How to identify what type of fillers are in a polymer?

Hello everyone, I have some PHAs blended with fillers and nucleating agents, yet I don't know what kind of fillers or nucleating agents. The producer has shut down and there's no way to get in...

24 February 2021 1,356 8 View

Can't recognize exact phase and PDF card no of Silicon carbide in XRD?

We have deposited silicon carbide on carbon substrate using one PVD technique. Due to amorphous behavior of SiC at low deposition temperature, we performed heat treatment of those films at...

22 February 2021 2,072 3 View

Why cannot world and community leaders be gentle? Where did ethics of care go?

The whole world is in a mess and paused. We all are tired of seeing hypermasculinized and destructive leaderships all around us. This world has seen enough of the aggressive patriarchal social...

23 February 2021 292 7 View

Why is ethics significant in business and how should one control unethical behavior ?

1. The significance of ethics to business and how to control bad behavior.

21 February 2021 882 14 View

Describe a serious ethical dilemma you have experienced. Use the 12 questions developed by Laura Nash to offer a solution to the problem?

Describe a serious ethical dilemma you have experienced. Use the 12 questions developed by Laura Nash to offer a solution to the problem.

21 February 2021 9,133 2 View

Discuss the extent to which morality in African traditional societies can be classified under the Natural Law theory of morality?

How can one classified African traditional societies under natural law

18 February 2021 7,334 8 View

How to derive equations for a resonant buck converter with ZVS?

I am not understanding how each author is deriving the equations and the working principle. Individual authors are giving their own working principle explanation for different circuit topology....

12 February 2021 496 1 View

Which ethical metrics is expected from an academic who is the owner or the creator of the measuring instrument?

Which ethical metrics is expected from an academic who is the owner or the creator of the instrument? The measurement tool will be applied to adults as an online form and a snowball sample will...

01 February 2021 9,188 3 View

Genus name priority from the same publication (Zoology)?

I came across a recent taxonomic work, where two genera were synonymized. Both genera were published in a paper in 1922 by the original author who revised the family at that time. The original...

19 January 2021 1,920 4 View

Will it be ethically appropriate to demand increased patient responsibility for own health?

The health care system is facing challenges when more individuals are not taking responsibility over their own health care decisions and actions. This is evident in narratives where patient...

16 January 2021 7,760 13 View

Environmental ethics, environmental values are their foundations. What is the core of environmental ethics?

the basis of environmental ethics is a value orientation on the influence of human actions

05 January 2021 7,984 6 View

What are the ethics of the teaching profession?

What are the ethics of the teaching profession? There are a lot of ethics that must be provided by the teacher mention it?

05 January 2021 9,535 54 View

Taoreed Kamordeen

@Ahmed

ChatGpt is a statistical tool that aids the analysis of quantitative researches from the end of a researcher. In fact, it is going to be helpful to the reviewer himself! Again, making use of the statistical package should not result in the rejection of an unplagiarized research work.

Sakban Rosidi

Ahmed Tijani Salawudeen

A reviewer of scientific work should have high scientific standards and sensitivity to academic ethics. Therefore, the judgments s/he makes are not just technical matters, including for example plagiarism and fabrication via ChatGPT. It would be completely unethical, I think, for an academic writer to use chatGPT. Or maybe I'm just too old fashioned?