If they are the same amino acids in the same order, you would not see anything, since the CD spectra are mirror images with respect to the wavelength axis. There are a few papers claiming that a fundamental asymmetry in nature (parity violation of the electro-weak nuclear force) can have chemical effects and may be responsible for the homochirality we observe in proteins I find that rather (well, highly, actually) doubtful.
In the attached paper (which is about the above effect, maybe you like the idea), CD spectra are shown related to your question in figure 1, which shows that if you add them up (as in a 50/50 mixture) there would be nothing left. Maybe the section Residual CD signal in poly- DL amino acids (p. 337) is of interest to you.
so there may be a difference in the purity or enantiomeric excess of the AAs used to make the peptide.
Also depending upon how big peptides are, they may be folded differently. This would require a chiral environment when they folded which would depend upon how you made them.
Also CD from peptides can be strong, maybe you don't have exactly a 50/50 mixture.
This is a question which has an unexpected answer. It is possible to "shift" this discussion by asking what is observed one mixes one mole of an L-isomer and one mole of a DL isomer. The question is then simply whether LL pair and a DL pair are identical. The question then is whether spectra are identical to only one L isomer present or something else. In the solid state in fact vibrational spectroscopy and Solid State NMR shows a 3:1 mixture is not at all the same as a 1:0 mixture. Have two publications on this on LLDL amino acids.
Walter Schmidt and Gert Van der Zwan and others: on a somewhat similar topic, if I have a sample of D and L free amino acids, can CD be used to determine the ratio of L to D enantiomers? I am not familiar with CD!
CD is circular dichroism. In essence, one isomer give a sine function whereas the other gives a -sine function. When both are present in equal amounts, there is no net signal. Instrumentation depends upon whether light is polarized towards the left or towards the right as a function of wavelength.
My recommendation is that if you want to separate D from L isomer, please investigate chromatography with a chiral stationary phase.