I have received comments from three reviewers. many of the comments are similar.
do i have to respond to the comments of all the three reviewers individually or can i write a consolidated response to all the three reviewers' comments.
please suggest me in this regard.
thanks in advance
You have to respond to the comments of all the three reviewers individually.
I feel you have received the comments of the reviewers separately. If it is the case then you need to respond to the comments of the reviewer separately like;
Reviewer-1
=============
Comment -1
Response-1
.......
...........
Reviewer-2
=============
Comment -1
Response-1
.......
...........
Reviewer-3
=============
Comment -1
Response-1
.......
...........
Srikanth Potharla, normally the corresponding author has to respond to each reviewer's comments even when some of the comments are repeated. What Shirshendu Roy has mentioned as an example for the author's response to the comments is correct.
I think you should have received three comments from three sites....you first see your perspective ...if your API score card and upgrading of your CV permits...i should add one more your capacity...permits..you can become reviewer of at least three books/journals/papers...
i think you respond to them separately...you talk to them..what is their demand ..what you want...and their perspective
here i want to share my one view
Now a days we only go for personal development apart from doing research...working for self interest...
But being a good human... if we want our organization our nation should shine...we always have to work for collective interest...um saying this in context with these API score cards...
- Badges
- Science topic
- Similar topics
- Methodology
- Research Methodology