I have written my first article and I would like to get some feedback, specially critical comments! I have thought that maybe this could be a good platform for that?
I am PhD student in History of Art, carrying out my thesis in the Department of History of Science in CCHS-CSIC (Madrid). This is my first publication about my work in progress and all the ideas about writing, sources, style, topics, etc. will be greatly appreciated. Many thanks to everyone who take time to read it and comment.
Article Alexander von Humboldt and British artists: the Oriental taste
Do you mean with "written" that you have published it already and that you are now wondering how to get some comments?
In the aswer above Richard assumes that you WANT to publish this article. If this holds true his comments are very vaild!
Just as an add-on: There are also so called pre-print archives (open access) where you can put your manuscript and invite colleagues to comment such as http://arxiv.org/
Personally, I would do this only with manuscripts which are under review and are more or less accepted already, maybe need some technical revisions etc. but it is clear that the manuscript will be published within a foreseeable future.
good luck!
This is a small article about my work actually published in a journal online in my department, therefore I wanted to get some feedback thinking in my future papers to a scientific journal so all your comments are really helpful!
Thank you very much.
Just a word : if you have already- published something, before publishing it in an other place check that you are OK with Copyrights. You are supposed to sign some agreement saying for instance that you are not allowed to do so for one year etc. Also be careful about publishing parts of your Ph.D. thesis : be sure that your University agrees doing so, and that you are not disclosing too much of it.
- Badges
- Science topic
- Similar topics
- Microbiology
- Assays