Hi, I submitted my revised paper in a journal after making major revision. First status was awaiting reviewer score then awaiting AE recommendation decision and today again showing status awaiting reviewer score. What I can conclude for these status?
Muhammad Aksar , it seems that (1) the AE sent back to the reviewer her/his review, probably because it was lacking some points or clarity (unlikely but possible), or more likely (2) there is more than one reviewer and the AE is waiting for the feedback form the other reviewer.
Probably of interest too:
https://service.elsevier.com/app/answers/detail/a_id/5971/supporthub/publishing/
Probably for the feedback/recommendation form the other reviewer.
That you are checking your MS status too often :) Seriously though, this could mean so many things that attempts to guess and infer anything about future decisions is not a good use of your time IMO.
suggest you just wait for the results of the review, hopefully it goes well and smoothly@David Moreau
It could be interpreted in a way that there may be more than one reviewers. As most of the journal have more than one reviewers. Only after approval from all the reviewers paper is accepted for publication.
The editor needs an additional reviewer report to reach a decision
- Badges
- Science topic
- Similar topics
- Filing