Give them both - a certificate is good from objective and measurable point of view - it will be part of their CV, while books are good awards from ''non-measurable'' point of view. Books are treasures that enrich their inner CV - their self-confidence, self-awareness, knowledge etc.

The student should be given both - a set of books as well as a certificate. The books will help him/her remember the occasion as well as benefit from reading them and the certificate will be part of the person's portfolio of achievements.

In my opinion, human nature always aspires to excellence and certificates of appreciation is one of the indicators of excellence , So the answer is ( a ) ... Books are the means to reach the level of knowledge to obtain certificates (As an indicator of continuing in the tender).

Certificate, I feel it is a good reference to keep.

I think that students like certificate more ☺

Give them both - a certificate is good from objective and measurable point of view - it will be part of their CV, while books are good awards from ''non-measurable'' point of view. Books are treasures that enrich their inner CV - their self-confidence, self-awareness, knowledge etc.

Certificate for students and free vouchers for cinema tickets or shopping...

Why not both?

I am Sure Appreciation Certificate is much more better than any other Appreciation given to the Students. It looks good on CV and remains for ever. No one knows or asks how many books you own.

Regards

Why not both?! A certficate of recognition is always nice. Also, it would be really thoughtful and useful to give a book as learning never ends!

Both

Both

Very interesting Discussion.

I really believe both are better, yet, we can do more to recognize top achievers by students like:

1. Give them a book, but give it to them during some events of the university or the school.

2 . Give them a Certificate during that ceremony.

3. Give medals for top 3 of them.

4. Take a memorial picture for this event.

5. Publish some article about this event with the pictures in the monthly or yearbook of the university or the school.

Both

Certainly a book. Most of students deserving this certificate are humble and intelligent people. They understand that a good book has a much higher value than a formal recognition of the activity they considered as a labor of love anyways. Yet, there could be a signed note inside the book that it's a recognition gift in memory of a great job by Mr/s XYZ in helping out his/her peers.

I agree with Nour Shakir

Books nd certificate- both r essential.

A book or a certificate? The ideal would be both book and certificate. However, in case of only one option, I prefer the latter (certificate).

both

Both

Book is the cause of knowledge

and certificate is the effect , so

book is preferable .

A certificate is necessary for employers and future colleges and universities. Books are necessary too, but it depends what they are.

For a young career man, I would suggest a certificate (inform of recommendation letter). This will assist him/her to attract Employers.

Both are necessary, in general anyone can get a certificate, but not all individuals can write books,Get the two, complement each other

Book is the first priority.

None should play a second fiddle. Both are really essential.

Thank you dear colleagues for your participation in this discussion. To me the premise of this question is multifaceted: more knowledge vs. celebrating the accomplishments; something that goes on the bookshelf vs. something that can help with show and tell....,

Books for excellence and certificates for career.

Both are presented to acknowledge students achievement. I personally like to get certificates and some students like it too. But other students enjoy reading books.

A certificate could be more effective I think.

We as a researcher have to create our footprint as our achievement, including:

So, it is difficult to nominate one of these items alone sir.

Thanks,

Emad

Both of them.

when you asking book and certificate. we can assume that the target person has equal capacity to achieve a prestigious certificate and write a quality book. If the certificate is like PhD or master or bachelor i will go for both adjusting my time. in case of other certificates.... i dont think a good quality book is comparable... but be sure that the person has the capacity write a real book or book chapter

Acerticate will definitely be better since he's in an early career stage

Any individual under a top achiever in institution has certainly with him the knowledge for the top achievement for which in order to maintain his standing it is obvious that he must have been endorsed in the library & the books & in this line it is better to have a certificate for his standing credit & performance

This is my personal opinion

My sincere thanks to all colleagues for making this a meaningful discussion, thank you Maham Muzamil , Mohammad Mehdizadeh , Emad Kamil Hussein , Joshua O. Ighalo , Joshua O. Ighalo , Najah Ali Mohammed , Shahab Uddin , Nadia H. Mohammad , Rohit Manilal Parikh .

Hi,

For a scientific research vocation, book is better.

In case of a professional career, certificate is more useful.

I think !

A certificate is meant for certifying the worthy recipient(s) about his/her/their accomplishment, performance, achievement or feat. It is a handy paper to show as a document for evidential proof or to attach in the personal CV to establish one's ability for a particular job.

Book is a wonderful material to gift a person as a token of appreciation. Packed with information, knowledge and words of experience and wisdom, it is excellent, time-tested and probably the best gift particularly to the students.

Both are apt and essential subject to situation, money, time and purpose.

Book(s) Prof Shah !!!!! I think that reflects the level of understanding one has , certificates and A to Z behind our names are not too fancy anymore !!! I like books and I admire Prof who have written books , well even I aspire to write book(S) ...

Both of them

Both!

Thank you dear colleagues for participating in this discussion, Nadia H. Mohammad , Nadia H. Mohammad , Ahmed Ouiddad , Ahmed Ouiddad , Amit Baran Sharangi , Aparna Sathya Murthy , Baydaa Y. Mahmmod , Carine Temegne Nono .

why you don't give them both?

Both

Both.

regards

of course , both

Both

Both

Such books or certificates are given to students or distinguished researchers because they will motivate students or researchers who are dedicated to giving more in their field of work

They deserve both!

Both ( book & certificate)

Both are required

Thank you dear colleagues for the amazingly informative value additions: Saba Abdulameer Kadhim Ziadi , Dr- Huda Shihab jari , Forat Hssoon , Mohammed Thabit Salih Al-Zubaidi , Dawood Mahdi , C. Lewis Kausel

I Think certificate is better than the book , it makes him/her proud and raise the power of motivations

A distinct answer from Dr. Dijana Vučković

I am with Dijana Vučković 's answer

Both are important

I think both are important ; to the student a certificate that they would be proud off as well as a book as a reward for their achievements

A certificate is better because it, at any time, refers to the excellence of the student.

Both but if I have a choice, I will go for certificate

Both are important for students

Give them a Certificate! Reason: I will not measured by the number of books I have but the certificate is a sign of qualification.

Most Students and Participants likes Certificate. Some likes Books to Read too.

Regards

If there is only one choice certificate is a better option as it will add a good line in their CVs. If there is possibility to give them both we should go for it as it would be an act of improving their CVs as well as their knowledge. However, the choice of the books in question should be wisely done so that they can gain at least something from the books. These days, the market is full of books that occupy only space but fail to transmit any form of knowledge.

شهادة اقوم بتاطيرها

A certificate I can manage

book is a better option

Thank you dear colleagues for participating in this discussion, Savita Rani

Dear Gulzar Shah ,

Certificate!!

You can buy a book but you cannot buy a certificate unless you earn it!!!!!!!!!

Regards.

A certificate will definitely be useful in future endeavors regarding further education and job applications. A very good book, on the other hand, will enlighten the students in some key aspects in life which a certificate cannot offer. Nonetheless, a book can always be obtained from book shops and libraries but certificate can not.

Following

today's digital ,internet,mobile world avoid books because f interested can be accessed easily , i recommend certificate with clear cut remark of appreciation

Help them to get a certificate and then you can write a book with their help.

Also, To write a book you need money

And for the money you need a certificate

(Only to those who follow the path of science and knowledge).

Both

Book

Certificate

Certificate .

Both: Book and Certificate

Certificate

Dear Gulzar Shah

Certainly, it is best to give a certified certificate that shows the best achievement of the student. In my opinion, the certificate highlights student achievement better and encourages him more than books and make him feel and proud of the value of his achievement. Regards

The certificate highlights student achievement better and encourages him more than books.