1- the geologic map in the area is an Incorrect definitive 2- in figure 4 , there is an unconformaty , but sand-blow rest on volcanic rocks 3- Sandstones in the study area is belong to Six hillls Formation not as mentioned in the paper 4- There is any post granitic dykes (false name), the granite is a younger type in Egypt, although is altered 5- There is any dacite (equivalent to granodiorite) in area , where the volcanic rocks that formed are alkaline types ( alakline rhyolite). consequentially, chemical analyses of dacite and petrography are fabricated. How dacite is found in a rift , within plate , it is very high fake, where the person write this paper doesn't understand any thing about the rocks and their environments, although undergraduate understands that very well. 6- the whole rhyolite rock is hydrothermally altered ( see concentration major oxides), congruently chemical analysis can't be used to make diagrams for classification or tectonic setting or petrogenesis. 8- figure 7d-e is found in another paper for the author entitled ( Rare metals mineralization in altered granites at Nusab El Balgum area, Southwestern Desert, Egypt. 9- from above we can conclude that the paper is a fake and fabricated.

I am the head project and there is not any map for the area by the Egyptian geological Survey, I have been collected the samples only without any person. I only made a geological map for area. I will no give any other, I have got fake paper and PH.D.