Hello VASP community,

I'm running into an issue with my band structure calculations for FeS₂ pyrite (1 cubic unit cell, 12 atoms) where the resulting bands appear non-smooth and zigzag-like (see attached plot). Despite tweaking several INCAR parameters, I haven’t been able to resolve the problem.

Calculation Details:

  • System: FeS₂ pyrite, cubic unit cell (12 atoms)
  • KPOINTS: 6×6×6 Monkhorst-Pack grid
  • INCAR: See below (full file attached)
  • Attachments: Band structure plot, INCAR file

Troubleshooting Steps Taken:

  • Increased k-point density — minimal improvement observed
  • Adjusted SIGMA between 0.05 and 0.15 eV — no effect
  • Used GGA-PBE functional (no hybrid functionals)
  • DFT+U applied (U = 1.5 eV for Fe)
  • ICHARG = 11, ALGO = Normal, NELM = 1 (non-SCF calculation using CHGCAR from prior SCF step)

Questions:

  • What are the common causes of non-smooth or zigzag bands in VASP band structure calculations?
  • Are there recommended settings or workflows to ensure smooth band dispersions, especially for non-SCF runs?
  • Could there be issues with my KPOINTS or INCAR setup (see below)?
  • I'm happy to provide additional files (POSCAR, KPOINTS, etc.) if needed. Thank you for your time and expertise!

    INCAR (excerpt):

    SYSTEM = fes2_bands

    NCORE = 2

    GGA = PE

    ISTART = 0

    ICHARG = 11

    NBANDS = 60

    ALGO = Normal

    PREC = Accurate

    NELM = 1

    ENCUT = 400.0

    EDIFF = 1e-06

    ISMEAR = 0

    SIGMA = 0.05

    NSW = 0

    IBRION = -1

    ISIF = 2

    ISPIN = 1

    LORBIT = 11

    LCHARG = .FALSE.

    LWAVE = .FALSE.

    #DFT + U settings:

    LDAU = .TRUE.

    LDAUTYPE = 2

    LDAUL = 2 -1

    LDAUU = 1.5 0

    LDAUJ = 0 0

    LMAXMIX = 4

    LDAUPRINT = 1

    More Dipta Mahanta's questions See All
    Similar questions and discussions