The choice between hydrodistillation and steam distillation depends on various factors, such as the plant material being used, the desired quality of the oil, the constituents being targeted for extraction, and the sensitivity of these constituents to heat.
Hydrodistillation is preferred in some cases because:
It can be more effective for tougher plant materials that require higher heat for oil extraction.
Some plants contain compounds not affected by higher temperatures and are better extracted using hydrodistillation.
It may produce higher essential oil yields than steam distillation for certain plant materials.
However, steam distillation is preferred for:
For plants with delicate compounds that degrade at higher temperatures, steam distillation preserves the quality of the extracted oil.
It can offer oils with more nuanced and complex aromas due to the lower temperatures used during extraction.
At present and in the recent decade, one of the best available methods for extracting natural bioactive compounds and secondary metabolites from genuine/original germplasms is the enzyme-assisted-extraction method. Of course, This method has a very high costs.