scientific and ethical conditions are necessary for Editor in Chief of scientific journals? and why?
I think that he must be honest and refuse plagiarism . He must also assist innovative piece of writing.
Regards
I think, it is best to redirect and re-ask this question to the journals editor board about the standard basis of nominated the editor in chief? Right?
Emad
Surely, editor in chief MUST have an excellent academic ethics beside his scientific toughness.
Emad
There are scientific and ethical conditions
Scientific conditions include
1 - five years experience is required in the field of jurisdiction
2. The scientific title
3 - five or three years after he held a doctorate
4- have supervision of the master's and doctoral thesis
5- Has published articles and research work internationally
6. Have sufficient time to evaluate articles and research work
The ethical conditions include:
1. Non-bias, ie to be impartial in the evaluation
2. Accurate verification of conformity of competence, specialists, backgrounds of other researchers
3. Has the ability to detect scientific fraud (Plagiarism)
4 - interest in his work
Experience in scientific research review.
Knowledge of scientific publishing rules.
Commitment to the principles of prevention of scientific plagiarism and the ethics of scientific research.
There is an International Committee of Medical Journal Editors who develop and implement new initiatives:
Acta Cardiol Sin. 2017 May;33(3):315-322.
Data Sharing: A New Editorial Initiative of the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors. Implications for the Editors' Network.
Alfonso F1, Adamyan K2, Artigou JY3, Aschermann M4, Boehm M5, Buendia A6, Chu PH7, Cohen A8, Dei Cas L9, Dilic M10, Doubell A11, Echeverri D12, Enç N13, Ferreira-González I14, J Filipiak K15, Flammer A16, Fleck E17, Gatzov P18, Ginghina C19, Goncalves L20, Haouala H21, Hassanein M22, Heusch G23, Huber K24, Hulín I25, Ivanusa M26, Krittayaphong R27, Lau CP28, Marinskis G29, Mach F16, Moreira LF30, Nieminen T31, Oukerraj L32, Perings S33, Pierard L34, Potpara T35, Reyes-Caorsi W36, Rim SJ37, Rødevand O38, Saade G39, Sander M40, Shlyakhto E41, Timuralp B42, Tousoulis D43, Ural D44, Piek JJ45, Varga A46, Lüscher TF47.
Author information
1
Chairman Editors' Network.
2
Editor in Chief Armenian Journal of Cardiology.
3
Editor in Chief Archives des Maladies du Coeur et des Vaisseaux Practice.
4
Editor in Chief Cor et Vasa.
5
Editor in Chief Clinical Research in Cardiology.
6
Editor in Chief Archivos de Cardiologia de Mexico.
7
Editor in Chief Acta Cardiologica Sinica.
8
Editor in Chief Archives of Cardiovascular Diseases.
9
Editor in Chief Journal of Cardiovascular Medicine.
10
Editor in Chief Medicinski Zurnal.
11
Editor in Chief SA Heart.
12
Editor in Chief Revista Colombiana de Cardiologia.
13
Editor in Chief Kardiyovaskuler Hemsirelik Dergisi.
14
Editor in Chief Revista Española de Cardiología.
15
Editor in Chief Kardiologia Polska.
16
Editor in Chief Cardiovascular Medecine.
17
Editor in Chief Cardio News.
18
Editor in Chief Bulgarian Journal of Cardiology.
19
Editor in Chief Romanian Journal of Cardiology.
20
Editor in Chief Revista Portuguesa de Cardiologia.
21
Editor in Chief Cardiologie Tunisienne.
22
Editor in Chief The Egyptian Heart Journal.
23
Editor in Chief Basic Research in Cardiology.
24
Editor in Chief Austrain Journal fo Cardiology.
25
Editor in Chief Cardiology Letters.
26
Editor in Chief Cardiologia Croatica.
27
Editor in Chief Thai Heart Journal.
28
Editor in Chief Journal of the Hong Kong Colleage of Cardiology.
29
Editor in Chief Seminars in Cardiovascular Medicine.
30
Editor in Chief Arquivos Brasileiros de Cardiologia.
31
Editor in Chief Sydänääni (Heart Beat).
32
Editor in Chief La Revue Marocaine de Cardiologie.
33
Editor in Chief Der Kardiologie.
34
Editor in Chief Acta Cardiologica.
35
Editor in Chief Heart and Blood Vessels.
36
Editor in Chief Revista Uruguaya de Cardiologia.
37
Editor in Chief Korean Circulation Journal.
38
Editor in Chief Hjerteforum.
39
Editor in Chief Heart News.
40
Editor in Chief Cardiologisk Forum.
41
Editor in Chief Russian Journal of Cardiology.
42
Editor in Chief Anatolian Journal of Cardiology.
43
Editor in Chief Hellenic Journal of Cardiology.
44
Editor in Chief Archives of the Turkish Society of Cardiology.
45
Editor in Chief Netherlands Heart Journal.
46
Editor in Chief Cardiologia Hungarica.
47
Editor in Chief European Heart Journal.
Abstract
The International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE) provides recommendations to improve the editorial standards and scientific quality of biomedical journals. These recommendations range from uniform technical requirements to more complex and elusive editorial issues including ethical aspects of the scientific process. Recently, registration of clinical trials, conflicts of interest disclosure, and new criteria for authorship- emphasizing the importance of responsibility and accountability-, have been proposed. Last year, a new editorial initiative to foster sharing of clinical trial data was launched. This review discusses this novel initiative with the aim of increasing awareness among readers, investigators, authors and editors belonging to the Editors' Network of the European Society of Cardiology.
Dennis
Dennis Mazur
The most important of all is his justice which implies that the editor will become unbiased. This is the leading key for authority (scientifically and ethically) of the editor.Best regards.
Hi,
I think that the scientific side of his character is very important as far as his work is concerned. Being secretive, fair and humble are very important also.
I am also agree with these answers both of them and I add open minds, supporting fairness, and rational objective. Thats all.
- Badges
- Science topic
- Similar topics
- Academic Journals