Recently, I have sumitted my article to a journal (23 June), the editor suggested that major revision, the two reviewers are also interested in my article and ask some questions for my experiment. I have sumitted my revised manuscript (27 July), then the editor told me I need to revise my manuscript thoroughly due to the language issues. In addition, the editor recommdated the journal editing service and emphasized that my article may be rejected due to the language issues. Due to the expensive cost of the journal editing service, I would like to take a cheaper editing service. I wonder that if I don't use the journal editing service, will the editor approve my article? Or should I withdraw the article and resubmit to other journal?
The contents of the letter are as follows:
Thank you for your submission . Our impression is that the above-mentioned manuscript could become suitable for publication in ***. However, the quality and clarity of the language used in the manuscript would benefit from a thorough revision. Implementing these changes will enable our readers to focus on the scientific content of your manuscript. You might consider using a professional language polishing service, such as *** Language Editing Services.
Please note that your submission may be rejected due to language issues. For one example, the logic of the Introduction Section is poor. Please revise the manuscript thoroughly, and we will decide whether or not the revised version can be sent out for external review.
It can be challenging to decide whether to use a recommended journal editing service, especially when considering the cost implications. Ultimately, the decision depends on various factors such as the importance of the journal, the level of language revision required, and the potential impact on the acceptance of your article. Here are a few points to consider:
Importance of the Journal: If the journal is highly reputable and aligns with your research goals, it may be worth investing in a professional editing service. High-quality language and presentation are crucial for acceptance in such journals, as they maintain strict publication standards.
Language Revisions: Assess the extent of language issues mentioned by the editor. If the suggested revisions are relatively minor, you may consider cheaper editing services or even revise the manuscript yourself with the help of colleagues or professional proofreaders. However, if the language issues are significant and could potentially hinder the understanding of your research, it may be wise to consider a professional editing service.
Budget Constraints: Evaluate your financial situation and research budget. While journal editing services can be expensive, they often provide a comprehensive review and editing process tailored to scientific writing. Cheaper editing services may not provide the same level of quality or attention to detail, so choose wisely based on your budgetary constraints.
Alternatives: If the cost of the recommended journal editing service is prohibitive, you can explore alternative options. Seek out other reputable editing services or consider reaching out to colleagues or mentors who may have expertise in scientific writing and can provide guidance in revising the manuscript.
Personal Capabilities: Consider your own language proficiency and editing capabilities. If you are confident in your language skills and can make the necessary revisions effectively, you may choose to revise the manuscript yourself or with the help of others.
In all cases, it is essential to thoroughly revise your manuscript for language issues before resubmission. Take the editor's feedback seriously and make the necessary improvements. If the editor has expressed concerns about the logic in the Introduction Section, carefully address these issues to strengthen your manuscript.
Ultimately, whether the editor will approve your article without using the recommended editing service is uncertain. However, focusing on improving the language quality of your manuscript is crucial for increasing its chances of acceptance.
If you decide not to use the recommended editing service, ensure that you thoroughly revise the manuscript for language issues, seek alternative editing assistance if feasible, and carefully consider the potential impact on the acceptance of your article. If you have concerns about the journal's requirements or the cost of editing services, you can also consider withdrawing
As long as you improve the language and clarity of the article to their expectations, you should be good. Doesn't matter how you do it.
- Badges
- Science topic