"Published a review on Hydrogen production with our collaborators from Iran and China" Do you know Hydrogen is future fuel which will replace other non renewal energy sources and will help to stop carbon emission and control global environmental changes.
Hydrogen is an energy carrier that can be used in internal combustion engines or fuel cells producing virtually no greenhouse gas emissions when combusted with oxygen. The only significant emission is water vapour.
@ Dr Dinesh Pathak .
https://www.synsint.com/synsint/article/view/68
"Do you know Hydrogen is future fuel..." Surely we know, providing that the problem of H2-storage is solved.
The review is confusing. The photocatalytic hydrogen evolution/formation/production is possible only via water splitting or in the presence of a sacrificial electron donor. The transformation of biomass to H2 can proceed without light. The bottle-neck of water splitting (photo- or electrolysis) is the catalyst for water oxidation, which is ignored in the review.
Dear
Asadollah Asadi
- 30.29
- University of Mohaghegh Ardabili
Farrokhfar Valizadeh Harzand
- 6.66
- University of Mohaghegh Ardabili
Is it ethical to recommend the post of your boss?
An article about H2 production that doesn't mention steam methane reforming, autothermal reforming, Partial oxidation, naphtha reforming or byproduct production for ethylene /olefins production seems to be quite deficient.
Yurii V Geletii commenting on a research platform like an amateur social media user is neither professional nor ethical either.
If you don't have to recommend the research it's ok, but commenting on why someone is recommending it, reflects your false ego. [Breakdown:
17.54% Publications out of 229.93]
Agree Steve Jacob ,I have seen that even in the published papers in top journals may have some errors, but it's normal. One may suggest opinions (since the review process has no limit) but one shouldn't denigrate a publication, it's unprofessional and unethical.
I hope people understand that by other methods the produced H2 is not green as those methods produce CO2 as well , ( disadvantage)
Criticism for positive improvement is good for science but criticism just for passion is not good , thx for comments.
I believe, that it's not ethical to advertise your own publication using the platform for professional discussions and question. There is no any question or suggestion for discussion in the post, just free of charge advertisement. I know very well this area and my comment on the review is professional. If "denigrate" means "criticize unfairly," then what is unfair in my post?
"but commenting on why someone is recommending it, reflects your false ego." I removed the word "useless" in my second post. My post is not the comment but question for the RG community. I open a new discussion: "Is it ethical to recommend the post of your boss?" https://www.researchgate.net/post/Is_it_ethical_to_recommend_the_post_of_your_boss
Thank God!
Another reason why here in US a professor is declared retired after 70!
The "EGO" increases a billion times with age!
After that, free time = twitter, facebook and now Linkedin & RG
Steve Jacob What is wrong and inappropriate in my first post? I criticized the review by identifying its faults. What was unfair or wrong? My second post was a question for discussion.
I consider your comments as a personal attack.
Dinesh Pathak Why do you consider my criticism as a passion but not as suggestions to look broader on the problem? Both criticism and critique are good for science.
Dear Professor Yurii V Geletii
I never did any personal attack on anyone since it's not a battle.
I just praised the US government's policies to retire a person in academics after 70.
Actually, you are doing the personal attacks since the beginning of this post by tagging everyone and highlighting their RG scores, not expected from a senior person like you.
Further, look at your RG score (only 17.54% Publications out of 229.93).
Plz don't mind, but it's reality.
Regards
Steve Jacob You did not answer to any of my questions to you.
PS I have never cared about my RG score
Yurii V Geletii It is sometimes ethical to recommend your boss' work - But it better be extremely good work and you should mention that he is your boss or at least your colleague.
- Badges
- Science topic
- Similar topics
- Engineering
- Petroleum Engineering
- Oil