We have used an in-house constructed Langmuir probe to determine plasma parameters (ion and electron densities and temperatures) and I was wondering if there are other methods and/or devices that people have used to characterise plasma environments?
In the Pulsotron August test campaign I measured using langmuir probes to measure at the same time than optical methods using silicon shottky photodiodes. As result it was better to measure the ion temperature using the photodiodes.
I can advise you when the test report (with plots) is released here in researchgate.
There are many possible approaches to measure plasma parameters - it all depends on what you want to measure and which plasmas you are looking at. Here are some examples:
brilliant! thanks Javier, much appreciated! :) We have been using optical methods to look at laser ablation plasma and encountered some challenges with that, so Im very keen to learn more about your experiment and the results of your comparison - my motivation for asking this question is that we're keen to measure spatial variations in plasma density and temperature within our RF plasma chamber (its about 50cm in diameter with the antenna in the centre), and seeking alternatives to Langmuir Probe methods.
Retarding field energy analyser is one more device which is more suitable in case of RF plasma since the first grid eliminates the RF fluctuations and other RF noise in the plasma. You can make a miniature RFEA and study the ion / electron energy distribution across the plasma. Your plasma chamber is large, so you can easily do this. Langmuir probe is complex in RF environment.
If you are looking at atmospheric-pressure plasmas, chapter 8 of the book "K. H. Becker, U. Kogelschatz, K. H. Schoenbach, and R. J. Barker, Eds., Non-Equilibrium Air Plasmas at Atmospheric Pressure. Bristol,: Institute of Physics Publishing, 2005" provides a comprehensive summary of the various techniques, with many examples.
It is not clear either single probe or double probe. You can also use triple probe to measure floating potential, electron density and temperature as a function of time in time-varying discharges.
I used three Langmuir isolated probes to measure plasma speed and another three optical sensors aligned with the Langmuir. We found that there is a lot of resistance variation in the plasma. Also we had problems because there was cross conduction between the probes (the three probes were isolated between them but the plasma acted as a conductor between the Pulsotron-2 plasma ionizer electrodes and the probes) and because the low resistance of the plasma was out of the range of our electronics, we need a different configuration to solve such problems and using a logarithmic amplifier. As result the optical sensors were a lot more accurate in our project at the moment.
We released the August test report, there you can find a plot where it is compared results obtained from Langmuir probe and photodiodes (chapter 5, paragraph 9)
Technical Report Pulsotron-2 August 2014 Technical Test Report
Optical emission spectroscopy can be used as diagnostic tool. Electron temperature can be determined from Boltzmann plot of emission intensity of several spectral lines. Electron number density can be obtained from Stark broadening of spectral line after de-convoluting the contribution comming from other broaening mechanisiums. This method is non perturbing and more favoured for reactive plasmas.
Gianpiero, it is a good idea, you may say that the electron (or ions) shields the electromagnetic wave?, would 2.45Ghz or 890Mhz go well? (it exists plenty high power RF modules)
I need also a good filter in the receiver. The problem is when receiving a pulse in a LC filter reacts generating a wave which frequency is the same it was designed. LC or wave guide flters has bad response to high speed variying wave amplitudes.
I collaborate to an experiment, using MW transmission. The technique was used in princeton by the group of Richard Miles. I do not experience, but I attach a paper I was coauthor where different measurements on electrons where performed.