If some one wants to check certain activity, say for example antimicrobial, for 4 or 5 different plants with aim to perform chemical characterization for plant showing highest activity, is this necessary to check all organic fractions (methanol, ethyl acetate, n-hexane, chloroform etc.) for the same activity or plant can be selected based on activity shown by initially prepared methanol extract?
I found a lot of literature in which researchers prepared all organic fractions of different parts (leaves, roots, fruits etc.) for all interested species (3, 4 or 5) and then selected single fraction for compound isolation. On contrary few papers represent methodology in which single plant was selected for detailed analysis based on activity shown by methanol extract for different parts (leaves, roots, fruits etc.) of different species (say for example 4). Methanol extract showing highest activity is then selected for fractionation and sub fraction with highest activity is chemically analyzed?
I think the second method is more time consuming and economic. Being an expert what do you suggest?