When calculating the Crop Diversity Index (CDI) for fields with mixed cropping systems, the approach to area allocation is crucial for accurate diversity assessment. Based on established methodologies and best practices in agricultural statistics, here are the recommended approaches for your maize-beans mixed field scenario.

Area Apportioning Methods for Mixed Cropping

Plant Density Ratio Method (Recommended)

The most objective and scientifically sound approach is the plant density ratio method. This method proportionally allocates the field area based on the relative plant densities of each crop compared to their pure stand densities:

Formula:

• Plant density ratio = (Number of plants of crop A in mixture / Number of plants of crop A in pure stand) : (Number of plants of crop B in mixture / Number of plants of crop B in pure stand)
• Pure stand means the count of plants of a crop (for example, beans) when it is grown alone on a field.
• Area allocation = (Individual crop ratio / Sum of all ratios) × Total field area

For your 1-hectare maize-beans field example:

Alternative Methods

Fixed Ratio Method: Some regions use predetermined ratios for recognized crop mixtures based on historical data and local farming practices. However, this may not reflect current cultivation patterns.

Seed Rate Method: Allocates area based on the proportion of seeds used for each crop, though this can be less accurate due to varying seed sizes and reporting inconsistencies.

Equal Division Method: The approach you're considering (dividing into equal portions) is the simplest but least accurate, as it doesn't reflect the actual crop proportions in the field.

Crop Diversity Index Calculation

The standard CDI formulas work with the adjusted areas from mixed cropping:

Gibbs and Martin Formula (1962): CDI = Σx² / (Σx)²

Where x = area occupied by each individual crop (using the proportionally allocated areas from mixed fields)

Shannon Diversity Index: H' = -Σ(pi × ln pi)

Where pi = proportion of total area occupied by crop i

Best Practices for Mixed Cropping in CDI

Data Collection Approach

Handling Different Mixed Cropping Systems

Intercropping (distinct rows): Use row ratios to determine area proportions Mixed Cropping (broadcast together): Use plant density ratios as the primary method Strip Cropping: Measure actual strip widths and allocate accordingly

Implications for Diversity Assessment

Avoiding Common Errors

Don't assign full area to each crop - This would artificially inflate diversity indices and create misleading results

Don't ignore minor crops - Include all crops that occupy more than a threshold percentage (typically 10%) of the field area

Consider temporal diversity - If crops in the mixture are harvested in different seasons, this may require different treatment in your diversity calculations

Impact on Diversity Indices

Mixed cropping systems generally increase measured diversity compared to monoculture systems. The Shannon-Wiener diversity index, for example, shows significantly higher values in intercropping systems than in sole cropping systems. This reflects the genuine increase in agricultural biodiversity that mixed systems provide.

Practical Recommendations

For your specific case with maize and beans in a 1-hectare field:

This approach provides the most accurate representation of crop diversity while maintaining scientific rigor in your diversity index calculations. The resulting CDI will better reflect the true agricultural biodiversity of your mixed cropping systems.

Example Calculations for a 1 ha Maize–Bean Mixed Field

Below are two worked examples using the plant density–ratio method to apportion the 1 ha between maize and common bean, based on typical pure‐stand and mixed‐stand plant populations.

Example 1: Moderate Intercrop Densities

– Pure‐stand densities

• Maize: 105,000 plants/ha (10.5 plants m⁻²)
• Common bean: 175,000 plants/ha (40 cm × 15 cm spacing) – Mixed‐stand counts in the 1 ha field
• Maize: 60,000 plants
• Common bean: 90,000 plants

Use x₁ = 0.526 ha and x₂ = 0.474 ha in your CDI formula.

Example 2: High‐Density Maize, Lower‐Density Bean

– Pure‐stand densities (same as above) – Mixed‐stand counts in the 1 ha field

• Maize: 90,000 plants
• Common bean: 50,000 plants

Use x₁ = 0.750 ha and x₂ = 0.250 ha in your CDI formula.

These examples show how plant counts translate into proportional areas for CDI calculation, yielding more accurate diversity estimates than equal splitting.

Thanks alot, I agree with you