The article titled "Exposing Postdocs to Multiple Institutional Types: A PROMISE-ing Intervention to Prepare Biomedical Faculty" discusses an innovative approach to postdoctoral training aimed at better preparing biomedical scholars for diverse faculty roles. Summary The article highlights the PROMISE Academy Alliance, an NSF-funded initiative designed to bridge the gap between postdoctoral training and the diverse needs of higher education institutions. The program exposes postdocs to various institutional types beyond research-intensive universities (R1 institutions), which are typically the focus of postdoctoral training. Key Findings 1. Exposure to Diverse Institutions: The program includes structured experiences such as campus tours, workshops, and speaking opportunities at different types of institutions within a state university system. This exposure helps postdocs understand the unique demands and opportunities at non-R1 institutions. 2. Impact on Career Interests: Surveys of PROMISE Academy Fellows indicate that these experiences are informative and positively influence their research and employment interests. The program helps postdocs build networks and receive mentorship from faculty at various institutions. 3. Support for Underrepresented Scholars: The initiative is particularly beneficial for underrepresented scholars, providing them with broader career perspectives and support networks. Implications The positive outcomes of the PROMISE Academy Alliance suggest that similar programs could be implemented across other university systems or regional consortia. By doing so, postdoctoral training can be better aligned with the diverse career paths available in higher education, ultimately enhancing the preparation and success of future biomedical faculty. Conclusion The article underscores the importance of diversifying postdoctoral training to include experiences at a variety of institutional types. This approach not only broadens career opportunities for postdocs but also addresses the misalignment between postdoctoral training and workforce needs in higher education. #postdocs #postdoctoraltraining #highereducation #education #articlereview #article #hamnicwriting #hamnicsolutions
The article titled "Exposing Postdocs to Multiple Institutional Types: A PROMISE-ing Intervention to Prepare Biomedical Faculty" presents a novel approach to postdoctoral training that aims to better prepare biomedical scholars for diverse faculty roles. It introduces the PROMISE Academy Alliance, a program funded by the National Science Foundation (NSF), designed to address the gap between postdoctoral training and the varied needs of higher education institutions.
Suggestions for Improvement:
Include Long-Term Career Outcomes:
Track and present longitudinal data on the career trajectories of PROMISE Academy Fellows to assess whether the program's impacts lead to sustained career success.
Clarify Types of Non-R1 Institutions:
Specify the types of non-R1 institutions involved (e.g., liberal arts colleges, community colleges) and how each type contributes to postdocs' career development.
Diversify Program Content:
Expand the program to include teaching experience, grant writing workshops, and leadership training.
Incorporate diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) training to help underrepresented groups navigate academic challenges.
Detail Mentorship Structure:
Provide a clear framework for mentorship, outlining how it is structured (e.g., one-on-one, group, formal or informal) and evaluate its effectiveness in supporting postdocs’ career development.
Evaluate Scalability and Replicability:
Analyze the feasibility and challenges of scaling the PROMISE Academy model to other university systems and provide a roadmap for its expansion.
Implement Robust Program Evaluation:
Develop a detailed evaluation framework, using both qualitative and quantitative methods (e.g., surveys, interviews), to assess the program’s effectiveness and make data-driven improvements.
Broaden Career Path Focus:
Expand the program's focus beyond faculty roles to include non-academic career opportunities in industry, government, and non-profit sectors, reflecting the evolving job market.
- Badges
- Science topic
- Similar topics
- Mathematics