This question arises out of the essay
Preprint Collective consciousness first
That essay observes thatlanguage is invented and improved by society collectively. The collection of ideas thus enabled creates a collective consciousness. Individuals then can acquire individual consciousness by acquiring language and ideas from the collective consciousness.
The essay further observes that collective appraisal is more indicative of collective problem solving than is invention that adds to a society’s lexicon and store of ideas.
Perhaps networking that enables collective problem solving is not just a means of collective problem solving but is necessary for consciousness itself. Perhaps appraisal of new words and ideas proposed by an individual or specialized group can enable the development of collective consciousness only if the words are repeatedly and continuously tested by the entire network. In other words, does deciding whether a new idea is added to the network’s collective information resources require appraisal by the rest of the network acing as an audience for consciousness to emerge?
And if networking combined collective appraisal leads to collective consciousness for human societies, should we be wary of networking computers?
The answer is: YES. I would suggest taking memetics into consideration. Richard Dawkins (1976), latest works of Daniel Dennett (Consciousness explained an especially From Bacteria to Bach. Susan Blackmore, and so forth.
My thesis that I'm currently working on focuses on the intersubjective nature of memes (as second replicators to genes) - meaning that the collective memetic pool is interlinked with all individual memetic fields.
Yes. Certainly, information exchange and collective appraisal of ideas are necessary for the emergence of collective consciousness, from the perspective of the Global Consciousness Project and other HeartMath projects such as the Global Coherence Initiative. An affirmative answer also applies from the perspective of wisdom traditions.
Yes, but the space for information exchange is very important.
The exchange of information directly from face to face is more than 1+1=2. This creates associations that usually do not occur online. It takes chemistry. That's why collective consciousness and ideas can be better built during joint meetings than at a distance.
Yes, information exchange and collective appraisal of ideas are crucial for the emergence of collective consciousness. Collective consciousness refers to a shared awareness and understanding that arises within a group of individuals. It is characterized by a sense of belonging, shared values, and a common understanding of goals or objectives.
Information exchange plays a fundamental role in the development of collective consciousness. When individuals share their knowledge, perspectives, and experiences with each other, it allows for the pooling of collective wisdom. Through this exchange, ideas can be evaluated, refined, and expanded upon, leading to the emergence of new insights and a deeper understanding of complex issues.
Collective appraisal of ideas involves the critical evaluation and analysis of different viewpoints within a group. It encourages open dialogue, constructive feedback, and the exploration of alternative perspectives. By engaging in this process, individuals can challenge their own assumptions, expand their thinking, and develop a more nuanced understanding of a given subject matter.
Both information exchange and collective appraisal of ideas foster collaboration, cooperation, and the integration of diverse perspectives. They help to bridge individual knowledge gaps and promote a shared understanding among group members. This shared understanding is a key aspect of collective consciousness, as it allows for collective decision-making, collective problem-solving, and the formation of collective identities.
In summary, information exchange and collective appraisal of ideas are essential for the emergence of collective consciousness. These processes facilitate the sharing and integration of knowledge, leading to a deeper understanding and a sense of shared awareness within a group.
- Badges
- Science topic