24 June 2022 2 3K Report

Hi, today I came across a strange problem. I found a panel data set online today (for the period 1980-1987). I first estimated a model with no fixed effects, but with time fixed effects (year dummies). As expected, one of the dummy variables was removed from the model (1980). I then used the fixed-effects estimator and observed something odd. Now, in addition to the 1980 dummy variable, the 1987 variable was also removed, as was the education variable. The education was removed because it is time invariant, but I can't explain the removal of the 1987 dummy variable. I had initially inferred mulitcollinearity, but then the 1987 variable should have been removed in the first regression, right? Also, the VIF values do not indicate a problem of mulitcollinearity. So what could be the reason for this? Could it have something to do with the -xtreg- command or fixed-effects transformation in general?

These are my commands:

reg lnwage union educ exp i.year, robust

xtreg lnwage union educ exp i.year, fe robust

Similar questions and discussions