I extracted gDNA, amplified the target regions (554bp, 226bp, 344bp, and 194bp), gel extracted the target bands and purified them. Then I did the ligation (3:1 insert to vector) at 4 C overnight, and then transformation following Promega protocol using JM109 competent cells with 50 ng DNA. After gel purification and ligation I got the target bands clearly on the gel. But after plating and 37 C for ~14 h incubation, I got ligation positive control grown well on the plate while both sample and transformation plates only got the blue dots, and the transformation control even grew into such small blue colonies as shown in the figure. The condensed small colonies may indicate that my agar plate was so wet or the plating density was too high, but I am confused whether the blue-only colonies in the samples and transformation control was due to the fail of ligation or the deteriorated competency of the cells. If the ligation was wrong, as there was no visible white colonies in the sampling plates, why the positive control showed a good result and the bands were observed at the right positions on the gel? If the cells were bad, why they all can grow good colonies?