When I plan to write a comprehensive review paper about a particular topic (X). My personal opinion, I should collect all articles about X, without care about the quality of these articles. After I summarize all of them, then I can create a section called "Evaluate X", in this section, I should put the high-quality articles. i.e., I should give a chance for all articles which published about X.
Is this right?
Yes, but after collecting the articles you have to evaluate them. Some of them may be just repeat of what others have done. Based on whether the articles have any contribution towards the build up of knowledge, you can decide to include or ignore.
No, find review articles from high impact journals and use those
I think yes. If you want your research paper to be cited more, then you should select high quality papers. Now how do you determine the quality? Check each article for quality seprately by using relevant Quality Assesment Tools.
- Badges
- Science topic
- Similar topics
- Social Psychology
- Attitude