How rigorous is the claim that both Saint Thomas of Aquinas (theist) and Aristotle (atheist) disagreed with Platonist reincarnation? My answer: highly rigorous because Saint Thomas of Aquinas claimed that the afterlife was without any reincarnation. While Aristotle believed in no afterlife at all. Belief in reincarnation is highly correlated with collectivism (see both East Asia and Plato's ideal government for Ancient Greece while he (Plato) believed in reincarnation). While both Saint Thomas of Aquinas and Aristotle believed in more individuation concerning ethics.