I submitted a paper for review in Management of Environmental Quality (Emerald). The first review took 4 months, and the 2 reviewers recommended minor corrections, though the editor settled for major corrections. I made the corrections and resubmitted the paper. This time around, the review process took another 4 months, summing up to 8 months under this journal. The second comment from the editor came with a rejection without any comments. I wrote the editor for any feedback or reviewer comments, but until today there has been no response. I do not know what might have happened.
Andrew Paul McKenzie Pegman
Write a letter accepting their response and that you have now withdrawn your paper. Then submit in another journal that values your amazing work :)
0 votes
0 thanks
- Badges
- Science topic
- Similar topics
- Chemistry
- Nanotechnology
- Nanostructures
- Thin Films
Similar questions and discussions