Axioms for Choosing a Nobel in physics ?

01 January 1970 1 5K Report

Hellow.

I am wondering whether we can establish a simple set of rules for choosing Nobel winners in Physics that will simply the process of deciding. I would like to propose the following three axioms:

Axiom I: Anyone who predicted a new force of nature should receive a Nobel prize.

Axiom II: Anyone who predicted an exiting force of nature should receive a Nobel prize.

Axiom III: Anyone who predicted an exiting force of nature is equal to a another existing force of nature which we know of should receive a Nobel prize..

Do you agree ?

Ohad Manor

concerning the first axiom, predicted beforehand with

i. above 95% accuracy

ii. six months before the actual discovery of the force

Badges
Science topic

More Ohad Manor's questions See All

Do you think can be any Uranium bearing rocks in Eastern part of Iran and western part of Afghanistan?

I want to know more about Uranium ore deposits in world.

11 August 2024 6,720 0 View

Do you think can be any diamond bearing rocks in Eastern part of Iran and western part of Afghanistan?

I want to know more about diamond ore deposits in world.

11 August 2024 2,167 1 View

What is the difference between mathematical R^4 space and physical 4D unit space?

We assume that the difference is huge and that it is not possible to compare the two spaces. The R^4 mathematical space considers time as an external controller and the space itself is immobile in...

10 August 2024 6,678 14 View

If Banks do not provide credit facility, what are the options available for FPOs and impact on producer’s income?

10 August 2024 8,198 5 View

Controlling for pupil light reflex when analyzing pupil size time course?

I used eye tracking to examine how participants from two different populations (A and B) react to an image. Participants in population A exhibit larger pupil sizes over time, but they also have...

10 August 2024 3,229 0 View

What are a “Farmers Producer Organization” (FPO) and its essential features?

10 August 2024 477 5 View

Strugglling with m6A dot blot any suugesstion ?

I have been doing the m6A dot blot for a while with no improvement, I am extracting the RNA, and I can see the dots although the three biological replicas give a different reading on the memberan...

10 August 2024 8,539 5 View

Do interactions between biosphere, carbon cycle, & water cycle impact global warming & interaction between atmosphere & hydrosphere?

How do interactions between the biosphere, the carbon cycle, and the water cycle impact global warming and interaction between the atmosphere and the hydrosphere?

09 August 2024 3,291 2 View

How to get moment output in Abaqus Standart?

I have input a moment load in module load Abaqus, i put my moment load on the node surface (using reference point). I have define moment in history output and make a set for moment too. But the...

08 August 2024 4,831 4 View

How is energy cycled through the Earth's climate system and how do matter cycle and energy flow through the rock cycle?

08 August 2024 8,162 0 View

Can anybody prove that AHP procedure is mathematically correct?

Dear colleagues In many articles I read that AHP has a strong mathematical foundation. I wonder if somebody can explain mathematically each of the steps in the AHP and ANP. Specifically, I am...

03 May 2024 5,607 4 View

Do military decisions achieve peace, or are peace decisions better, less expensive, and more sustainable?

I believe that the cost of establishing peace is much lower than the cost of war and is many times more sustainable, and it is possible to start from the axiom that $1 spent on economic and social...

26 February 2024 4,286 3 View

Are the 3 Particles 2/3e : Up, Charm and Top and also -1/3e : Down, Strange and Bottom not on a plain?

The Geometric axiom wants that 3 plain particles are sitting on a circleline. Why should the Quantummechanics be stronger then the Geometry? If not then the virtual quarks (gravity points of...

18 December 2023 2,100 0 View

Is this the right example to intuitively realize axioms of the set theory, namely axiom of specification and axiom of extension?

Whenever we construct a set, we do so in such a manner that always we have a certain property or a set of properties that the members of the set specify. Even when we create an arbitrary set of...

11 October 2023 6,224 0 View

Important questions about Quantum Finance?

...

30 September 2023 6,488 1 View

Aside from the usual explanation and from your scientific and cognitive point of view, do you have another opinion on this compatibility?

Giuseppe Piano was the first to establish the axioms of vector space, where the group axioms were linked to the axioms proposed regarding the second law, “number multiplication,” with a basic...

15 September 2023 4,234 1 View

Is it possible to define a Topology on a set X without taking the whole set and empty set in the collection of open sets?

Generally, a topology tau on a set X is defined considering the following three axioms: 1. The whole set X and empty sets are in topology tau. 2. Arbitrary union of any collection of open sets of...

06 September 2023 6,502 10 View

Can the Primitive Notions (Categories) and Axioms of Mathematics, Physics and Philosophy Converge?

We see many theories in physics, mathematics, etc. becoming extremely axiomatic and rigorous. But are comparisons between mathematics, physics, and philosophy? Can the primitive notions...

28 October 2022 2,756 100 View

What is the difference between a Knowledge Graph and Ontologies?

P1: Ontology + Data = Knowledge Graph (KG) P2: If a KG is the sum of these two summands, it follows: C: An ontology is a framework for a KG As a framework, an Ontology consists of person data,...

12 December 2021 941 3 View

What was the main intuition behind the original definition of a Reinhardt cardinal?

I'm interested in how William Reinhardt first came up with the intuition behind the idea of an embedding from V into V as a possible large-cardinal axiom. Was he sad when it turned out not to be...

10 October 2021 9,229 0 View