Traditional built environments are surely complex adaptive systems. To prove it, one needs to use a topological representation of wholeness based on either natural streets or natural cities, e.g.
Article A Topological Representation for Taking Cities as a Coherent Whole
My thesis deals with the continuation of hypotheses presented by Pr. Benhamouche, which were introduced in two of his papers published in Nexus Netowrk Journal (papers attached below).
In other words, I aim to verify the hypotheses using a quantitative approach.
My goal is to demonstrate:
- That the fabrication of traditional urban tissues in Algeria is a process, (such as traditional carpets) produced by Islamic rules?
- Which morphogenesis of traditional tissues? Is this processes that follows Islamic rules based on: emergence? Fractals? Chaos?
- Whether the Islamic city is a complex system? or and adaptive complex system?
- What modeling is more accurate in this context: cellular automata? Agent Based modeling? Network analysis? .....????
I suggest fractal geometry under the third definition: a set or pattern is fractal if the scaling of far more smalls than larges recurs at least twice:
Article Ht-Index for Quantifying the Fractal or Scaling Structure of...
Instead of fractal dimension, you could use ht-index or fht-index to characterize fractal or complexity of a fractal:
Article How Complex Is a Fractal? Head/tail Breaks and Fractional Hierarchy
The reason I suggest ht-index or fht-index is that box-counting fractal dimension is a bit too mechanical; see this editorial:
Article Editorial: Spatial Heterogeneity, Scale, Data Character, and...
After a large study of different complex systems based methods I'm considering to use graph theory and network theory to analyze urban street patterns (based on toplogical indicators).
Among these software tools ArcGIS and NetworkX which do you recommand to use?, what are your suggestions beyond this set ?
We are all the prisoner of Descarte's mechanistic thinking. To make smart built environments as well as beautiful artifacts, we should get out of the prison, and re-think under Alexander's organic thinking: