Because- 50% of water and 50 % of methanol get the antioxidants that are both "water soluble- phenolics, flavonoids, glycosides, proteins, carbohydrates, vitamins" and "methanol(lipid) soluble- say lipids, carotenoids, chlorophylls, steroids, sterols, etc." more effectively, than either one of them in isolation! So, of course the chances to get both the worlds is easier than only MeOH/H2O.
However, if you isolate separately in H2O and MeOH 100% each, and then combine 1: 1 ratio, then it would be far more effective than 50%-MeOH-H2O! Experiment this as well!
The mixture of MeOH-H2O or ETOH-H2O extracted much polyphenols compounds than each solvent individually. In your case you will have in your extract much macromolecules like tannins...These macromolecules can influency the activity of the radical dpph