I'm stuck trying to understand the physical meaning of a model in MAUD that seems to describe my data really well. I have data on CeN (in the NaCl structure) in a diamond anvil cell, but the {200} reflections are shifted to lower angle compared to the {111}. Data and refinement without macrostrain is attached.

Now, I find that using the WSODF model and refining the 230 and 120 coefficients makes the fit about as good as one could hope for (refinement also attached). I just don't really understand the following:

1. If I calculate the macrostrain under the model options, do I just multiply that onto the three unit cell axes to get the "true" unit cell that I observe?

2. If I do so, the values I get (a = b = 4.609 Å, c = 4.663 Å) then result in the same unit cell volume as the unstrained case (where a = 4.635 Å). Is this a coincidence?

3. What is the physical picture of this strain model? It clearly doesn't break the cubic symmetry (the {200} should split if it did), but how does this agree with the strained unit cell parameters above?

4. Am I overfitting the macrostrain?

Cheers from a scientist battling with the physical meaning his model (don't we all).

-------------

Notes for people who might actually look at the data:

- The Cu is there on purpose as a pressure standard.

- There is also some anisotropic broadening going on, with {200} being much narrower than {111}, but that does not confuse me so much. I don't know if I should be able to see a connection to the macrostrain.

More Morten Bormann Nielsen's questions See All
Similar questions and discussions