In reference to Marisa Wexler’s article (May 29, 2025), “Childhood adversity tied to greater MS risk; quality of evidence low”, I would like to raise a broader and more critical question:
If the study implies a causal link between early-life trauma and later MS risk, does this mean that children growing up in chronic conflict zones—such as Gaza, Yemen, or Ukraine—are categorically at high risk of developing multiple sclerosis?
How does the research account for those who endure profound adversity yet show no signs of MS? Might this be a case of overgeneralization—where complex psychosocial and cultural resilience factors are overshadowed by a narrow epidemiological model?
From an anthropological and ethical standpoint, is it not essential to challenge such potentially pathologizing narratives that may inadvertently marginalize the lived strength of entire populations?
“Childhood adversity tied to greater MS risk; quality of evidence low” :
What kind of evidence is Ms. Wexler looking for? Psychological links between any adversity of fate and Jean-Martin Charcot's terminal MS-associated hysteria? Autoimmunological links between autoimmune reactions on pediatric brain trauma and those on intramuscular injections of brain tissue in guinea pigs?
Why overshadow facts on MS, as made evident on www.ms-info.net by ever-new experimental models, like the given epidemiological model?
The findings reported by Levinson (2025)—that most children with MS present with slow-growing brain lesions and that changes in disability or cognitive scores are not significantly associated with SEL—illustrate that the disease follows non-linear and complex pathways. This reinforces the critique I raised regarding the Wexler 2025 model: reducing MS risk to a single variable, such as early-life adversity or trauma, represents an overgeneralization that fails to capture the full spectrum of human and biological complexity underlying multiple sclerosis
Emergence and growth of MS lesions await a better short-term monitoring of their actual development in time.
- Badges
- Science topic
- Similar topics
- Biological Science
- Bioecology
- Systems Ecology
- Landscape Ecology
- Connectivity