01 January 1970 1 2K Report

Some reviewer comments are legendary for their brutal honesty or blunt critique. Here are a few examples that have sparked debates (and maybe some tears):

  • “This manuscript should be used as an example of what not to do in research.”
  • “I recommend this paper be rejected and its authors carefully guided away from further research in this field.”
  • “This study answers a question no one is asking.”
  • “The paper is so poorly written, I cannot determine whether the science is good or bad.”
  • “The authors need to reconsider their career paths.”
  • Share your own stories or thoughts—how do we turn criticism like this into something productive? Let's discuss!

    More Elaine Lu's questions See All
    Similar questions and discussions