I'm asked by a reviewer to extend my manuscript (which is about cognitive radio network) to include one real-world network scenario. The exact words are:
The authors should augment the paper with one particular "real-world" network scenario and demonstrate the functioning and performance of SE-CRN (my scheme name).
Now I'm in puzzle. What is meant by the real-world network scenario? Should I assume simulation parameters exactly those stipulated in IEEE 802.22 standard and this will suffice to satisfy the reviewer's question? or he means to implement my scheme in real experimentation?
Dear Abdullah Khan,
I think he needs to prove what you are imposing in your research with real evidence on the ground, that's what a real example is needed, or I can assume he wants your experimental work, as you mentioned earlier.
Good Luck,
Muhammad
Muhammad Ibrahim Abdulhamid It means simulation or analytical results bear no significance in the reviewer's book?
It mainly depends on the core of your research paper. I suppose you have to add both simulation and any other analysis of data, this make your work more significant.
My best wishes
- Badges
- Science topic
- Similar topics
- Methodology
- Research Methodology
- Research Papers