The following literature may be useful for your studies
There is no difference of quality between the different forms of energy. However, observations do show that heat and work are not equal: one can always transform work to heat, but the reverse is much more complicated and often not possible. For instance, we have learned in the second chapter that in order to do mechanical work, e.g., a gas-system has to change its volume against an external pressure. If this external pressure is zero and an ideal gas expands (certainly irreversibly) no work would be done and no heat would be absorbed. That's puzzling because the internal energy doesn't change; there is no energetic "motivation" for the gas to expand. Nevertheless, the gas will evenly fill the larger volume that became available. What's the "driving force" for that change? Clearly, there must be some property, called entropy that governs the transformation of systems.
Dear Dr. Toleda; I am sorry to say that you guys are trying to rediscover classical thermodynamics by going back to Carnot (1824), Joule (1840-45), Helmholtz (1847), and Clausius (1850). To day we are adopting the formulation of Max Born (1921), which is surpassed in rigour and clarity all earlier attempts. Prof. Dr. Krishna is on the right step by spelling the secret word of 'Entropy' or ' the Second Law of Thermodynamics after by making a very successful 'gedankeexperiment'. Best Regards
Heat is a form of energy in transition states between two or more bodies that are at different temperatures. The quality of this form of energy as its exergy (are related concepts) depends on the value of the difference in temperatures. In the case of isothermal process heat is transmitted to the same temperature (hot and cold sources) and does not imply that thermodynamic irrreversibility ideally this case being a well explained in the theory of heat engines Carnot limit.
Okay! Then please try to answer the following questions using Carnot Concept. What is Temperature? What is energy? What is work? What is Heat? How heat, energy and work are connected analytically? What is the mathematical definition of entropy? What type of thermodynamic quantity is changing during the infinitesimal isothermal process under constant pressure or volume? Thermodynamics is a mathematical science like algebra or group theory, which relies on the few hypothesis, and the rest is the logical manipulations (calculus). (Einstein).
The classical engineering thermodynamics as You and I, we learned in mechanical engineering departments can not take us too far. I was trained as a regular Navy Officer, and graduated first in my class. But I learned real chemical thermodynamics (including the irreversible one) by taking special courses from the Chemistry Department at Stanford while I was majoring Material Science and Solid State Physics (minor) in the years of 1960-1965. Best Regards
Lest us take the case of solidification of an alloy at constant temperature and pressure:
WE define a new thermodynamic function 'enthapy' as H=U+ PV . Then write the first law as dU = T dS-PdV and combine this with definition of enthapy. You get: dH=TdS +VdP. For an isobaric process dH=TdS
This formula can be used to calculate the enthapy change during the isothermal and isobaric solidification process by simple integration operation, which gives: DH=TDS = DQ, where Q is heat by definition (D finite difference operator) which is for one mole quantity of alloy known as the Heat of Fusion or Enthapy of Fusion under the constant T and P. Similarly, one can define another function known as Gibbs Free energy by G=U-TS+ PV, and one shows by calculus that dG = -SdT + VdP,which becomes zero for the isothermal and isobaric process under the equilibrium. dG=0 or DGT,P=0. This is very imported relationship in most of the chemical reactions, which takes place in atmospheric conditions. One can also show using the definition of entropy by Max Born (1921) that for irreversible (natural) processes dGT.P EQL =0
One may do the same approach for the isothermal and isovolumic processes by defining Helmholzt Free energy F=U-TS, and using the differential form such as: dF= -SdT-PdV to show DFT,V=0, and dU=TdS by integration for one mole of alloy: DU=TDS = DQ Heat of Fusion under the isothermal and isovolumic condition: QED Similarly dFT.V EQL 0.
True in a reversible isothermal process you can transform a given quantity of heat into an equivalent quantity of work.
But the crucial point is that, you must do that cyclically (repeatedly). If you do an isothermal cycle, you will notice that you will not be able to convert heat into work, because at the end of the cycle the heat reservoir suffers no change and we don't get any work output. Therefore, the isothermal process doesn't acknowledge the difference in quality of heat and work (or other forms of energy). Besides, we can convert a given amount of work into an equivalent quantity of heat in a cyclic process. Therefore, such a process also will not allow us to understand the fact that the quality of heat and work are really different!
It is therefore necessary for us to perform a cyclic process where heat is the input and work (or any other form of energy) is the output. When we do this we will find that we don't get an equivalent quantity of work (or any other form of energy) output for a given quantity of heat input. This is the reason that leads to the conclusion that the quality of heat and work (or any other form of energy) are different.
With the development of special theory of relativity by Einstein (1905) and later put into geometrical format in terms of union of space and time by his mentor Hermann Minkowski (1907), we enlarged the law of conservation energy to include MASS into the scenario.
When a closed system undergoes a process, no mass changes occur. Similarly when we consider a cyclic process no mass changes occur.
Therefore, inclusion of mass changes in the 'enlarged' law conservation of energy, need not bother us, for the processes we are considering - conversion of heat into work.
Dear Roberto I am sorry to say that it is nonsense to talk about the quality of heat if one wishes to stay in the domain of thermodynamics. There are many forms of energy the heat and mass are few of them. What is important that is the universal law of conservation of energy!!